Milk and dark chocolate peanut butter cups and a chocolate buckeye

Peanut Butter Classics

Regular price $15.00

Peanut Butter Cups or Buckeyes - two variations for the peanut butter lover...

A classic American favorite, our Peanut Butter cups are each crafted by hand using real, creamy peanut butter- it is not like any peanut butter cup you have experienced!  Pro tip: eat them upside-down for the best peanut butter to chocolate ration in every bite.

Alternately, our Peanut Butter Buckeyes are an Ohio classic named for the state "Buckeye" tree, which produces a nut that looks like the Buckeye candy.  A rich, fudge-y peanut butter center is enrobed in milk chocolate.

Please Note, Buckeyes only available in Milk Chocolate.

Share this Product

More from this collection

Customer Reviews

Based on 4 reviews
Shelly i.M.C.
Decadent pb cups

I have been enjoying the dark chocolate peanut butter cups for years. I thoroughly delighted in each one I savored. These are absolutely fantastic!

Robert S.
Peanut Butter Classics

My granddaughter looks forward to these peanut butter cups with every occasion I buy them for her. They are absolutely delicious!

Kathy R.
Peanut Butter Classics💕

I love peanut butter and these are the best!! Soooo delicious.

barbara S.
Peanut Butter Classics

Wonderful! Everybody loves them. The Peanut Butter Classics taste just right —- not too sweet filling, but sweet enough and smooth and creamy —- perfect with dark chocolate!